Strawman? I wasn't even trying to characterize anyone else's point, I was just trying to list some significant improvements over x86.
> The simplest possible mitigation would have been to disallow an instruction from spanning a 64-byte boundary.
Sure, that sounds good. But before this you hadn't even mentioned any problems with split instructions that need to be mitigated.
(You did mention decoding without a known entry point, but a rule like that doesn't guarantee you can find the start of an instruction. And if it would help to know that a block of 64 bytes probably starts with an aligned instruction, that seems like something you could work out with compiler writers even without a spec.)
I did forget to mention the requirement that you can't branch into the middle of an instruction. If you have both of these constraints then you can unambiguously determine the location of all instructions in any aligned 64-byte block, including at I$ fill time.
Implementing this would require instruction fetch to take an exception on line-crossing instructions (which must be illegal) and a change to the assembler to insert a 16-bit padding nop or expand a compressed instruction to maintain the alignment. There is nothing needed from the compiler (or linker AFAICT). JITs will have to be aware though.
You'd also need to guarantee that there are no constants or other non-instruction data in the same cache line as instructions. If that's a reasonable constraint then sure, that sounds like it would be helpful.
> The simplest possible mitigation would have been to disallow an instruction from spanning a 64-byte boundary.
Sure, that sounds good. But before this you hadn't even mentioned any problems with split instructions that need to be mitigated.
(You did mention decoding without a known entry point, but a rule like that doesn't guarantee you can find the start of an instruction. And if it would help to know that a block of 64 bytes probably starts with an aligned instruction, that seems like something you could work out with compiler writers even without a spec.)