Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Human Rights Watch have a very good write up on Singapore here:

https://www.hrw.org/report/2017/12/12/kill-chicken-scare-mon...



And Singepore wasn't invited to Biden's summit for democracies ...


Source?


I found this: https://www.state.gov/participant-list-the-summit-for-democr...

Wow, I was surprised to see that Sri Lanka was not on the list. Does anyone know the story behind that? Also, Nepal and Bangladesh are missing. That is also strange. All of them are certainly (proud) democracies!


Why would a “Summit on Democracy” matter other then to show who the US are pals with and which ones (by omission) would rather be pals with other (opposing) powers?


It is all about China.

They also somehow managed to censor Audrey Tang of Taiwan (another computer scientist turned politician) live on video-link.

Just goes to show how carefully orchestrated all this is.


Woah! AT (Audrey Tang) [1] is an amazing person. For those unaware, she is a "minister without portfolio for digital affairs" (a mouthful!) in Taiwan. I tried to Google about this but couldn't find anything. Can you share a link?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audrey_Tang


https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/13/us-appears-to-...

US appears to cut video feed of Taiwanese minister at summit


You can google it.

The point is; Singapore doesn't toe the US line on China and therefore gets HRW and similar thrown after them.

Which is absurd as Singapore is by far the best-governed country in the neighbourhood.


I don't normally do this but...it's "toe the line".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toe_the_line


Thank you.


>The point is; Singapore doesn't toe the US line on China and therefore gets HRW and similar thrown after them.

Human Rights Watch isn't part of the American government. They've criticized the US numerous times. So much so that they are concluding that the US is trying to discredit them.(1) Singapore might simply not have been invited because they're not a real democracy.

>Which is absurd as Singapore is by far the best-governed country in the neighbourhood.

Best governed (according to you) != democracy.

_____

(1) https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/10/23/us-seeks-discredit-human...


I suspect there's a reasonable argument to be made that under certain circumstances, democracy is a substantial barrier to optimization of governance. Between Soviet/CCP long-term planning capacity and the fascists' making the trains run on time, industrial totalitarianism has a track record of getting the job done.

That said, all that job-doing is at the mortal expense of anyone who disagrees, stands in the way, or can be scapegoated for standing in the way. Also, woe be upon you if your leadership selection process picks a dud (compare the damage an incompetent megalomaniac leader in a limited democratic system can do to the same result in an absolutist dictatorship).


Singapore is a democracy, claiming otherwise is just an idiotic insult.

You see the pattern of the same group holding power for a very long time in some countries, in particular in times of high growth (rather than oscillating between blocks like the US).

For example LDP in Japan or the socialdemocrats in Sweden.

It really doesn't mean that they are not democratic.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: