Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It does not. Really the strings just never get long enough that O(n²) would be catastrophic; the maximum possible length is 2e5.


2e5 is enough for making a naive O(n^2) solution to get TLE.

This is likely due to the fact that in AlphaCode's solution the "inner O(n) loop" is actually a memmove(), which is optimized to be insanely fast.


> AlphaCode's solution the "inner O(n) loop" is actually a memmove(), which is optimized to be insanely fast.

Again, it is not. CPython does not do these things.

The web page says, and this is corroborated in the paper,

> Solutions were selected randomly, keeping at most one correct (passes all test cases in our dataset) and one incorrect sample per problem and language. Note that since our dataset only has a limited number of test cases, passing all tests we have cannot completely rule out false positives (~4%), or solutions that are correct but inefficient (~46%).

The “54th percentile” measure did use estimated time penalties, which you can see discussed in Table 4 in the paper, but 1553D was not part of that.


> CPython does not do these things.

Again, it is.

https://github.com/python/cpython/blob/2d080347d74078a55c477...

This is the memmove() I mentioned above. Like, I actually perf-d the code and confirmed this is in the hot loop.

> but 1553D was not part of that.

Someone submitted this 1553D code to Codeforces and it passed: https://codeforces.com/contest/1553/submission/144971343


Apologies, I thought you meant ‘optimized’ in a different sense, not in terms of how list.pop is implemented, as AlphaCode wasn't involved in that. You are entirely correct that list.pop uses memmove.

> Someone submitted this 1553D code to Codeforces and it passed

Ah, well that shows you have a 2 second time limit, which is quite a lot of time! Not quite enough to empty a 200k element list with list.pop(0)s, but not far off; a 140k element list squeaks in under the time limit for me.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: