Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>I shouldn't [ be allowed to buy food ]

Thanks, that should be all we really need to see here.

> The externalities should be charged where they occur

You can walk to the farm and negotiate with the farmer to buy from him rather than allowing it to be transported back by diesel, are you doing this or is this just more hypocrisy?



> >I shouldn't [ be allowed to buy food ] > Thanks, that should be all we really need to see here.

I've never said that I shouldn't be allowed to buy food. I simply believe that when I do, I should pay the true cost of it.

> You can walk to the farm and negotiate with the farmer to buy from him rather than allowing it to be transported back by diesel, are you doing this or is this just more hypocrisy?

You have an oddly black and white view of the world. There are plenty of things that I think we should change that currently benefit me. I can participate in the system while still recognizing its flaws and arguing that they should be fixed. I can't reasonably opt out of everything where I disagree with some aspect of it. Do you believe that politicians should vote against all bills that they disagree with any part of?

I think the wealthy in my country should pay more taxes than they currently do. I make more than the median income so this would probably result in me paying more taxes too. I can hold this view without donating part of my salary to the government. I'm against capital punishment. If I see someone committing a crime they could receive the death penalty for I'll still call the police. Do you believe that these views also make me a hypocrite?


>I've never said that I shouldn't be allowed to buy food. I simply believe that when I do, I should pay the true cost of it.

A distinction without a practical difference. It's effectively impossible to buy food at the true cost. Therefore you don't think you should be allowed to buy food.

>If I see someone committing a crime they could receive the death penalty for I'll still call the police. Do you believe that these views also make me a hypocrite?

Yes. If you narc someone out to a system that metes out the death penalty and you disagree with it, then you're no better than the executors.

>I think the wealthy in my country should pay more taxes than they currently do. I make more than the median income so this would probably result in me paying more taxes too. I can hold this view without donating part of my salary to the government

Yes this is highly hypocritical. You want to demand others do something at gun-point that you won't even do voluntarily.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: