Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Remind us how what the police officer did wasn't vehicular assault and potentially homicide.

Remind us how physical injury is a reasonable response to a traffic violation.



I don't want to defend him, what he did was *wrong*. He should absolutely face consequences for gross over-reaction. I never said his response was reasonable given the circumstances.

But the way the story was presented was extremely biased. I believe the US cops are trained to actually use the "pit" maneuver to stop offenders who otherwise refuse to stop. In this case, he should've known better - but one can totally see how an asshole cop would interpret the situation as "lady is refusing to stop, I need to compel her to do so".

I guess what I'm saying is that it wasn't a totally random act of unprovoked cop violence.


I think that it doesn't matter whether it was 'provoked' or not: the police should be professionals who prioritize public safety above all else, and this is a total failure.


Ok, let me retry:

> An Arkansas woman says she had no safe place to pull over in July 2020

The Arkansas woman was lying. That's it. I was not defending the cop, and never did I claim he was behaving professionally.

Still. The Arkansas woman was lying. She had plenty of safe space to pull over. Seemed relevant to me.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: