Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Within the mix of retirees, digital nomads and young families fed up with issues including the costs of housing and healthcare, Trumpian politics and pandemic policies,

Given that Trump is not the president since a long time and California is the most progressive US state, I'd think that Californians are fleeing progressive politics, not Trumpian politics.



I was born in the US and came to Portugal 2.5 years ago. After dealing with the typical California urbanite, I feel for my people. The issue isn't just the price increases in many things in my home country. It is also that these people, once they are allowed to vote in Portugal, will push for the same stuff that they did in California and screw my politically/socially moderate home country. Very sad, maybe I will start voting accordingly to counterbalance this.


Californians are fleeing high prices, not progressive politics. The progressive politics there have attracted people for decades, so much so that it’s become unaffordable.


Yeah, no.

Paying $3M for a house in SF but public schools aren’t an option because “math is racist” is fleeing progressive politics.


Show me your data, and I’ll validate your claim.

The great weight of stories published on this question indicates that people are vacating to live less expensively/more lavishly, not to be with people less politically progressive. Are there a few such people? Sure. But they’re hardly the majority.

There are a lot of reasons why people choose not to send their kids to public school. Sometimes it’s because they perceive the public school as unsafe. The primary reason isn’t because parents disagree with the math curriculum, but because they want to give their kids a leg up in the fiercely competitive race to get into a top university. When everyone around you is wealthy and smart, parents try to find whatever advantage they can.


“Parents want schools that are safe, they want their kids good at math”.

Two things progressive schools don’t offer.


Says who? It feels like you’re just trolling and don’t have any actual useful information to add.


https://www.sfexaminer.com/news/projected-k-12-drops-in-enro...

That many families aren’t leaving the Bay Area they are just pulling their kids out of school.

Why if not the progressive curricula?


The article you cited provided the primary reasons why enrollments are declining:

""" Slow population growth: In the 1960s, the population in California grew 26%. Between 2000 and 2010, growth slowed to 15%, then 6.5% between 2010 and 2020. In 2020, there was a net migration loss of 0.5%, signaling that the state’s projection for the next decade, a slim 5.2 percent, may be high.

Aging population: In 1970, the median age in California was 28; in 2020 it was 38. In 2030, it will creep up to 40.

Birth rates: In the 1950s, the birth rate in California was 25 per 1,000 people; in 2020, it was 12. The previous low of 12.6 was in 1933, during the Great Depression.

Delayed marriage: In 2020, for the first time, women’s average age of marrying was over 30. """


It dropped 5% just this past year. The population did not decline 5% this past year.

And sorry, "slow population growth" is the same as "increasing population growth", so it doesn't explain a decrease.


Ah yes, fleeing progressive California to a country with with an actual socialist party in charge of the government.


That party is only socialist in name. LOL




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: