Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

By tablet stuff, I mean reading, taking notes and sketching. No app ecosystem does it like iPad OS'.

The problem with the Surface Go isn't the hardware, but the fact that it runs Windows, a system that just isn't made for these things.

The most ridiculous part was being forced to "save or discard" drawings before I could close an app. I had to painstakingly pick a location and name for each file. It felt like using Photoshop, not a notebook. Every app sucked in a different way. In contrast, most iOS ones are decent to great, and there are far more options for readers.

That's on top of the regular Windows problems. I spent the first day just doing updates and disabling bloat. As a tablet OS, it's incredibly clunky. I didn't get to the part where it wakes itself up and fries itself to death in my laptop bag, but I heard that it's still an issue.

The iPad was so much better at its task that it's not even funny.

Now I take my iPad everywhere, and if I intend to do more work, I pack my Macbook. It's not heavy enough to make me consider Windows ever again. However, I'd consider an old 12" Macbook to shave a kilo off when I travel.



I've got an ipad in a drawer somewhere. Also work has been trying to push a macbook on me. After trying it I said no: I stick to my Fold, because I like it better, both for the hardware and the software.

It's smaller and does everything multiple separate device would be needed for.

> I had to painstakingly pick a location and name for each file.

First world problem lol!!

For old apps, I have an AHK shortcut to save files by ISO date. However, it's rarely a problem with modern apps. And if you close them without saving, most of them will bring back your unsaved work. Even Word does that!

> By tablet stuff, I mean reading, taking notes and sketching. No app ecosystem does it like iPad OS'.

For comics and mangas, I use Takiyomi (technically, it's an android app, but WSA makes it seamless)

For taking notes, I use ZimWiki and Windows stickies

For sketching, I use OneNote.

> The iPad was so much better at its task that it's not even funny.

We must have very different uses, because between even just Takiyomi+OneNote vs an ipad, indeed it's not funny for the ipad.

> That's on top of the regular Windows problems. I spent the first day just doing updates and disabling bloat

Well, don't look further for the root cause: "disabling bloat" often causes more problems. I only remove very specific things. For updates, I use Windows Pro and usually defer them until I want to reboot. When I read the problem people report with windows, it's like they live in a different world.

> Now I take my iPad everywhere, and if I intend to do more work, I pack my Macbook

I just take my Fold everywhere - nothing else is needed, but I've got a bluetooth keyboard for comfort if I want to type a lot.

On the Fold, I can draw with a Wacom pen - no need for a separate device like the ipad, because most windows tablet and convertibles also have a touchscreen.

If I need to work, I have Windows Terminal and everything I need to code. ZimWiki means my notes can be converted to HTML and published.


Everything here is a compromise or a workaround.

Onenote particularly is a hard no for any sketching in terms of actual artistic output.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: