Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Side note, has anyone watched the TV show based on it? Trailer looks amazing but haven't had the time to dig into it.


I haven't yet read the books (they're in the queue, but I'm currently going through Peter Hamilton's Commonwealth Saga/Universe[0] first)... but the show was both really interesting and really awful, imo. It had a good premise initially, the bit about mathematical formulae that can guide humanity through existential struggle, and then it just kinda dropped the ball on that concept beyond a few scenes. The show apparently introduced a concept not really emphasized in the books, according to others I've talked to, in the form of "Empire" - a singular man, cloned multiple times, with a youth version (Dawn), an adult version (Day), and an elderly version (Dusk), some of which overlap beyond just the 3 generations. That was one of the more interesting bits of the TV series to me, since the rest was somewhat muddled and incoherently presented. Acting ranged from decent to awful. Too much mystery building for a show with no guarantee of a renewal. Worth a shot if you're bored and into SF though.

[0]: https://www.goodreads.com/series/108563-commonwealth-univers...


I couldn't get into it. They changed some of the characters and beginning plot and I hate when hollywood does that.


I was also really excited about The Wheel of Time series that came out on Prime (especially since Sanderson was consulting on it), but it really disapointed for the same reasons. The Expanse was spot on though. I hope someone picks the show back up so they can finish out the series.


The early episodes of the Expanse were easily the best Sci-Fi TV I can remember watching. Was still good towards the end but definitely didn't keep me as glued to the screen as the first series.


Yeah. I read that they went over budget and had to rewrite the last couple episodes to finish our season 6. It was good but felt more rushed and incomplete.


Yeah it's quite watchable. To the point I signed up to Apple TV just for that show (and promptly unsubscribed once I'd finished, been meaning to check when the next series is out).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: