Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The charging voltage has to mach your battery voltage

Nope, the charging circuitry (most commonly) and/or BMS (less common) inside the car can handle this easily.



In nearly all DC charge setups the charge voltage (ie. the voltage on the wire you plug into the car) does match the battery voltage.

Sure, it's technically possible to do voltage conversion on the car side, but it either requires expensive and heavy hardware (A device that can convert 300 kilowatts from 400v to 800v isn't cheap!), or it requires funky use of the electric motor inverters and coils for voltage conversion instead - which in turn constrains the design and forces compromises.

In either case, you probably with have ~3% efficiency losses, which effectively increases the total energy bill for the customer over the lifetime for the car by 3%, which might be thousands of dollars.


> In nearly all DC charge setups the charge voltage (ie. the voltage on the wire you plug into the car) does match the battery voltage.

Except the battery pack on the car is 300V to 400V depending on the model car, but the grid voltage is 120V (mobile charger) to 480V (Supercharger station). Some EVs are 800V even. So tell me again how the input voltage matches the battery voltage? ;)

The reality is that either the charger or maybe the BMS, either inside the car or elsewhere, is not only stepping up or stepping down the voltage to match the battery, but also rectifying the AC grid input into DC for the battery packs.

> In either case, you probably with have ~3% efficiency losses, which effectively increases the total energy bill for the customer over the lifetime for the car by 3%, which might be thousands of dollars.

There is more than 3% efficiency losses usually and some commercial charge providers handle that differently. Most directly expose the overhead by charging for “kwh used” whereas car shows “kwh stored in battery”, but Tesla does (or did until recently) just charge for what was “stored”.


I expect 95% of chage is done by normal charger, so not so much financial difference by DC efficiency loss.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: