Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You can, I just confirmed by bank account with Dwolla this morning.

One of the guys asking Dwolla questions on Twitter was a 4th generation jeweler, who regularly has $10k and up transactions. He was very eager to learn about the merchant APIs. He could probably save $500-$900 on a $30k ring if the transaction was made with their service. There are a million examples like that out there.



Your post made me do two double-takes.

1) People buy $30k rings!? 2) People put $30k on a credit card!?


Yes and Yes.

At that level you are not using the card for credit, but rather as a replacement for cash. And who wants to write a check when you can use a credit card instead?

It's faster and safer to use a credit card, plus the merchant doesn't have to worry that the check will actually clear.

And using a debit card when you have a lot of money in your account is not safe. So credit card wins.

And for that same reason dwolla will stay rare for such transactions - without the consumer protection laws that credit cards have people will just not use it with strangers.

It will be used exactly as the article describes: To send money between people who already have a relationship, but it will rarely be used for purchases.

Basically he's replacing checks, not credit cards.


> Basically he's replacing checks, not credit cards.

Meanwhile, in large part of the developed world, banks do direct transfers nationwide and checks are dying rapidly. I'm 36 and Norwegian. Before I moved to the UK, the last time I'd seen a check in person was when I was 5-6 years old, and I'd never had a checking account as they're no longer offered as standard in Norway.

While checks are still more common in the UK, they are being phased out, and direct account to account transfers are now down to about 2-5 hours during the business day.

Dwolla faces a massive risk that the big banks will just wipe out their value proposition overnight by deciding to copy the European model.


So how does it work? You go to some event, and need to pay to get in. No cash, and no credit card - how do you do bank transfer in such a situation?

Or the school wants the kids to send in a fee to cover some trip they are going on? How do you do it without a check?


I don't know how everyone else does it but in my case:

1). You remember to take cash and if you forget, you always have your cards on you and an atm is usually no more than a few minutes away. You can also increasingly pay for these sorts of things via mobile phone.

2). The school sends their bank account details along with the trip information and I setup a same day wire transer online.


The school sends you the account number and you send money to that account number.


Exactly. It just doesn't make sense for me to have a checking account with $10k or $20k in it earning 0% interest just in case, when I can have a credit card with a $20k limit in my pocket all the time that I can use if I ever need it.


Can you pay instantly with it, just like with a card?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: