Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Tangential anecdote. I like to think about physics a lot and I regularly write things down.

One time, I was so excited about the concepts I had been playing with, that I decided to go talk to a Stanford physics professor (who I had never met).

I just went to campus, started walking around the physics buildings and ran into him. He was gracious enough to let me walk with him for about 10-15 minutes while we talked. At the end he said my stuff was interesting, but it would take a lot of time to develop, that he was too old to help me and that instead I should talk to a younger professor at Caltech (he gave me his name).

I thanked him for his time and help, then looked up the professor he mentioned, saw a phone listed for his office and called. The Caltech professor picked up the phone, I explained the situation to him and then he told me I had been pranked.

He said that it was a running joke between them to “send” the clueless/crazies to each other.

Needless to say I felt like crap. At the same time it made me realize how unnecessarily cruel some people can be.

These were super recognized professors in their fields, one of them a Nobel prize winner. Both probably incredibly busy/demanded people. Yet, they go out of their way to make others feel shitty.

I wonder how they treat their students.



Name names? Shitty people should be at least known to others.

Its also literally the antithesis of what a professor, an educator, should be.


What good is this anecdote without the name of the snotty elitist professor?


That's fucking funny. I would be so amused if that happened to me. But then the second guy called you clueless/crazy, so I guess it depends on how the perpetrators executes the prank.


Might be funny from the outside. But I put myself out there, felt very vulnerable and then they just made fun of me.

They could have told me that whatever I was saying didn’t make sense, they could have pointed the way to books/classes/papers, but instead they just bullied me.


I can recognize this prank and others. Also love harmless fun. What about circulating a paper around his other peers, asking for feedback, adding the professor name as co-author?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: