Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is cool. But on the other hand, it's not the way the world was intended to be. If someone sends you a nasty message which they immediately delete: then isn't the world a better place? It's a somewhat philosophical and moral question...


When I see a message pop up that gets deleted before I get a chance to read it, I'm left wondering for ages what it could have been.

I'm generally of the opinion people are free to say (almost) whatever they like to me, and deal with the consequences. Virtually though, I guess it's a little different. People type things they wouldn't say face to face, so maybe being able to delete them before they're read is the fix for that.


Quite the opposite, it’s precisely how things are intended to be - and pretty much always were. The law states clearly that correspondence belongs to its recipient.


"The law" isn't universal.


No law is universal, but this one is I believe quite well established in most jurisdictions.


it's not the way the world was intended to be.

What? History should always be immutable; let's keep it that way.

If someone sends you a nasty message which they immediately delete: then isn't the world a better place?

No, I think it's better to just apologise for your past actions.

It's a somewhat philosophical and moral question...

Agreed.


History is anything but immutable... The past, however, is immutable. History is the story told by the prevailing parties over generations of violent conflict


> History should always be immutable;

I feel like you're agreeing with my point. Capturing a deleted message that you would never have seen is effectively changing history.


Capturing a deleted message that you would never have seen is effectively changing history.

No, if it's sent then it's sent.


The human mind does need privacy and the assumption that something you say wont last forever, go to a select group only or you can deny it or people forget is ingrained in our social hardware.

Then comes along computers and all that is out the window!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: