Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think the issue boils down to known and controllable disruption (i.e. you are an active participant) or unknown and uncontrollable disruption in which you just receive whatever happens as it happens. The problem is nobody will vote for controllable disruption and many will actually vote to accelerate and grow the problem so we're stuck rolling the dice. Examples of this are things like municipalities, or counties, or states (in the US) banning construction of new wind turbines in their county (this happened in Ohio recently) and then funneling government money into subsidizing fracking or oil and gas production.

We're going to get these wars anyway because countries with a military will just start conflicts over resources and where nations break down many will just resort to anarchy and suffering there. We're already seeing this with Russia invading Ukraine where there are fascist goals but also geographic goals with control the fertile Donbas region and then also the subsequent usage of gas as a weapon against Europe. This is just the beginning.

It's hard to see how technology will solve this problem because it's a political and social problem and not a technology problem. No amount of carbon capture technology can build solar power in India while they're at war with China over water from the Himalayas ya know? No amount of technology can stop (at this time) Republican governments from banning EV installations or using government money to incentivize oil and gas industry development for donors.



Wars over resources are far different than a ‘war on global warming’, which is what I was referring to.

The technology would have to be similarly transformative as nitrogen fertilizer was - which is what avoided the whole Malthusian population trap in the first place.

We don’t know what we don’t know there, frankly, so hard to say if it exists or not.

Co2 capture and most GHG emissions though have a serious thermodynamic challenge which says ‘not easily’. Once the clock spring is unwound, it’s really hard to wind it back again.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: