Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The decline of BART and Metro is a good metaphor for the decline of American government competence. The 1970s saw a wave of state of the art automated train systems built in SF, DC, and ATL. When we moved to DC in 1989 the Metro offered a smooth, comfortable, computer-controlled ride.

Today those systems are in shambles. The automatic train control infrastructure in the DC metro has deteriorated so much that it was turned off in 2009. Today a DC Metro ride is uncivilized, like the ancient system in NYC, with some poorly trained driver jerking you to a stop at each platform. Not only that, but the 6 minute headways built into the original system were relaxed to 8 minutes, and even that is not achieved in practice.




> Today a DC Metro ride is uncivilized

This is quite the exaggeration. I use the DC metro multiple times a week (but no longer daily). I also prefer to use public transit while traveling. The ride is similar to elsewhere in the US and about 50% of abroad systems.


In my experience, if you ride trains in Singapore or Tokyo and then visit the US, the word ‘uncivilized’ really does come to mind.



The headline of the third article on your list:

> Joo Koon train collision: Some passengers cried and there was vomit in the train, says witness

“Vomit in the train” would never make a headline in an American newspaper.


> Today a DC Metro ride is uncivilized, like the ancient system in NYC, with some poorly trained driver jerking you to a stop at each platform.

I ride DC metro regularly and this seems like quite the exaggeration.


Do you remember how it was in the 1990s? It was modernity. Now it’s just like all the crappy systems designed before indoor plumbing was universal.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: