Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

What immediately scares me is every post on the website by the link having a title. To me inventing a good title arguably almost seems the hardest part of writing at all. A microblog should let you dump a thought quickly without requiring you to name it first.

Also, individual post URL is hidden to deep. You apparently have to open the post, scroll down, click "share", click "copy link", and even that element is not a real link. As soon as I see a post/preview/listing I want to be able to middle-click it to open it in a background tab or Ctrl+click it to copy/whatever.



Hey! I'm sorry you find the title intimidating. You could just use a random character in your title, or even a whitespace, to achieve the effect of a title-free place to post.

Regarding the individual URL, if you don't want to click to copy it using the current flow, you could just CMD+Shift+C to copy the URL?


> You could just use a random character in your title

As a mild-OCD perfectionist I'm literally grinding my teeth imagining doing it this way. If there is a place for a title a post I write has to have a good title or no title at all.

> or even a whitespace to achieve the effect of a title-free place to post.

If title doesn't have to be unique this already seems as an acceptable compromise.

> Regarding the individual URL, if you don't want to click to copy it using the current flow, you could just CMD+Shift+C to copy the URL?

Nice point. Any chance I could copy a post URL or open it in a background page straight from the posts list? I scroll the feed, see some read/bookmark/share-worthy posts and I would normally middle click them to get them all opened in background tabs.


> As a mild-OCD perfectionist I'm literally grinding my teeth imagining doing it this way.

Haha sorry I understand what you mean!

>If title doesn't have to be unique this already seems as an acceptable compromise.

Yes, currently the title doesn't have to be unique. The platform will just generate a unique URL for each post based on the title, and append a digit if necessary.

> Nice point. Any chance I could copy a post URL or open it in a background page straight from the posts list?

It was initially set up like this, but a bunch of users (mainly on mobile) complained that they didn't like the fact that each post opened in a separate tab. They wanted to just read a post and scroll to the next one easily. That's why I've moved to the current format. Maybe I could make it behave differently on desktop. I'll keep this in mind.

Thanks!


I get what you're saying. Specially if you think of it more as a microblog that you share toughts.

How do you feel about timestamps as titles (and URLs)?

Maybe having an option to use a title or just a timestamp.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: