Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

As much as I love seeing this kind of hardware stuff, the problem with "pick and place" is the vision integration, not the motor control. That's where everybody gets stuck.

It's not a "pick and place" until you've got the cameras and alignment working.




You're not wrong, but it's also not the focus of the article. There's a lot of complexity in a pick and place system, for example I didn't even touch on the entirely separate board that's controlling the tool head. If I tried to capture all that at once, I'd be writing an entire textbook, not an article.

If you're interested in how the LumenPnP handles vision, you can check out the OpenPNP project which handles all of the computer vision involved.

https://openpnp.org/


Those are the same non-functional machines I have seen for the past decade in some cases. All of them got to vision and got stuck.

I truly hope your machine gets past that point, because it would be really good to have a genuine, open-source pick and place machine. With the current advances in ML/AI and running on graphics cards, it should be within the realm of a hobbyist nowadays.

I wish you good luck and hope to see your stuff on one of the crowdfunding sites one day.


I think you're working on some outdated assumptions. As mentioned in the article, the LumenPNP project is successful. Myself and many others have been successfully assembling boards with it since earlier this year. Lumen isn't my project, it's just the machine that the board I designed is intended to work with.

https://github.com/opulo-inc/lumenpnp




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: