I found it dull and repetitive, and loved Eternal. I have no idea whether I'm in the minority, but just because someone is a horrible person ethically doesn't mean that their taste in video games is horrible too.
Fair, I can definitely see why players will enjoy one or the other more. They are quite different in what mechanics they tailor for. I was put off by the demeanor of the creative director in the documentary, who it turns out wasn't Marty at all but Hugo Martin.