Where do people live where going outside for a walk for an hour is that dangerous? I'm pretty sure even if you lived in a super high crime rate area you could still find times to go outside for a walk during the day. Unless we're talking about extreme scenarios like living in an active war-zone.
It’s not just about being attacked. It’s just there’s no pedestrian infrastructure. Or it’s all in shambles. Or you constantly have to leave the broken or slippery sidewalk and walk through cars.
Manila is such a place. I love walking every day. I really tried to walk there and it’s… hard.
I love walking, and having lived in cities that make it difficult and frustrating I noticed some ways that make it engaging and motivate me to do it anyway.
Frustrating points about walking for me include poor road layout (e.g., to get anywhere from your neighbourhood you must first walk to basically-a-highway then walk alongside it for a time), poor air quality, noise from traffic, reckless rule-breaking drivers, missing sidewalks, stray dogs, etc.
— I find places to go. Find places you want to visit for whatever reason, maybe to grab some food or coffee, to sit and read or people-watch, and alternate between them. I don’t like repetitive exercise without any other purpose than exercise itself so I don’t just walk—I am getting somewhere. (Sometimes I don’t have a specific place in mind but I know there’ll be something I need in the general direction, like coffee. This method generally requires a denser urban area to work.)
— Shoes without heel support made a significant difference to my walking routine. They force me to land every step similarly to how I would do it if I were barefoot, not right on the heel like cushioned sneakers teach us. That combined with keeping neck and extremities relaxed at the same time really makes my body remember that there’s such a thing as abs, because suddenly every step engages abs. Maintaining this form is also a bit challenging, mentally more so than otherwise. As a result, even though I may be going somewhere, I walk more slowly and I feel better about the process.
— I monitor air quality with AirVisual; when it’s green it’s a motivating factor to get fresh air (what if tomorrow it changes to orange/red for a week, and I will want to enjoy a walk… better do it while I can).
— Carrying a camera and taking photos when I feel like it makes me more attentive to my surroundings. Some say always having a camera means I don’t live in the moment, but I suspect this hobby instead helps with that. It also requires walking to see new scenes worth photographing, even bicycling doesn’t work so well.
— Noise-canceling headphones address noise pollution, plus walking is probably the best time to listen to an audiobook or a podcast if not music.
These all help me get into the right state of mind and cope with frustrations.
Mostly unsolved problems:
— Reckless drivers. I find the only way to deal with this is to either submit or to put yourself in danger. The former can ruin your day and the latter obviously can’t be recommended. In some cities making yourself more noticeable (if you don’t naturally stand out then through high visibility clothing) may actually reduce the danger enough, but it wouldn’t help say in Seoul where they speed through red lights barely noticing anything (thankfully however in Seoul you can route your walk mostly away from wider roads or bridges where this happens).
— Heat is a problem depending on the latitude, if I don’t wake up early enough I may be demotivated to go out that day.
— Combined with all other frustrations, suburban-like sparsely populated environment tips the scales for me. I never could really enjoy walking in Chiang Mai for example, it’s boring and the probability of encountering a pack of stray dogs is bothersome.
I’ve never seen a city that doesn’t have some way to go on walks.
All the terrible unwalkable cities in the US are called that because you can’t actually walk to anything useful. In other words, those cities that require a car to do errands, go shopping, get to work, go to school, etc.
But for exercise—walking for walking’s sake—it’s usually doable. It is nice if you can get the walking “for free” by combining it with ordinary life, though
There are no sidewalks in my parents' suburban neighborhood. You just walk among the houses, and there is nowhere to go. It's no surprise that we spent our childhoods at the mall.
These dead neighborhoods are connected by high traffic roads, also with no sidewalks, each more boring than the last, each loud and dangerous.
In Germany, wherever you go, there are little paths. They go along fields and streams, between houses, from park to park. It's easy to find a pleasant place to walk from your home. It's something I dearly miss when I visit the home country.
It's cars. Rural america is not walkable unless you live near nature trails. You're walking on roads with no shoulder and people happy to run you over.
Rural America is a) not nice to trespassers(and you're bound to walk on private land if you're off the main streets) and b) is even more car dependent than urban areas, so human or animal paths usually don't exist.
Sure, but you'll run into rural people that will just chase you off with a shotgun instead of calling their lawyer and once you've had that experience once, its enough. Ahmaud Arbery is a tragedy that paints this picture pretty well.
There are so few paths there! Germany has layers of paths wherever you look, but they're suspiciously absent from Canadian cities.
In many places, you'd be walking directly on a road with fast vehicles that don't expect pedestrians there. Look up "stroads" and you'll understand why it sucks to walk in North America.
Safety is not just safe "from attack". It's also safe from traffic, safe from breathing in drastically worse air outside compared to inside, safe from the elements, etc. etc.
