Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

People are ultimately going to do that. And if we really can't figure out a book written by an AI from that written by a human, then what's the point of all of it? Eventually good authors will still succeed as their writing style will not be squeezed out of the grand summation of all the writings in the world.


There are a lot of negative consequences:

1. Entire classes of skilled jobs are eliminated, only the most elite writers and artists can make money

2. Value for story creation gets concentrated in the few companies that own and operate the best LLM's and best stable diffusion models

3. Society becomes more fragmented because we are all watching different content

These are just a few I'm able to think of in 2 minutes.

It's a common mistake to assume all technological progress is an unadulterated good. Just look at all the unanticipated negatives that came out of the computer revolution, like every technological revolution before it.


Agree that the assumption is that progress, no matter what, is good and healthy.

If one considers how inefficient humans are (daily consumption, heating, transport..etc) and how in comparison computers are extremely efficient (once they have been built), you realise where "pure" progress will take us.

Ephemeralization is the term Buckmeister-Fuller used.


I'm not at all assuming all technological progress is an unadulterated good - in fact, nothing is, everything would have a downside if it has an upside. All I'm saying is it's still bound to happen and we can do nothing about it.

It's not the first time that 'entire classes of skilled jobs' have been eliminated. It's the natural side effect of automation and has happened with every generation of new products. Industry automation might have taken millions of jobs away so far to give us better products faster. Tomorrow my job as a usual developer might be gone to these AI tools (though it's a far fetched thought), and I have to be prepared for it, and re-skill/up-skill myself if I ever sense that day is about to arrive.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: