Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Given the extremely fast and extremely comprehensive U-turn, it seems like a lot of people near the top did understand the community very well.

Somehow, one person or one small faction made a different decision, and the overwhelming feedback proved it was the wrong decision.



Well, there were two attempts at more minor climbdowns before this capitulation, so it seems more likely that the immediate financial impact from mass unsubscriptions was a motivating factor than prior understanding from the execs who were largely pushing this strategy if leaks are to be believed.


I think if they actually understood the community then they would not have needed this poll, which demonstrated near unanimous opinions. I would not blame anyone for believing that this retraction is simply a means to avoid larger problems and that there will be similar future attempts to make the same unpopular changes. It isn't just a misunderstanding of the community's opinions, but that they just demonstrated that they have almost no clue what those opinions actually are.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: