The big concern is the contagion spreading. All banks are vulnerable to failure if deposits are taken out quickly, especially in this market where assets have taken a huge hit over the last 12 months.
FRB wants people to believe the contagion is limited to tech and that they have limited exposure to it, so that folks don’t take deposits out en masse. If people start to think that it’s unstable, then they’ll take money out and it’ll be a death spiral like SVB.
If people don’t get their access to their cash by Monday (or a week later at latest), then any rumor of liquidity issues at any bank will lead to a bank run. Once you know / experience it, bank runs feel like a legit thing to do.
I know people who had their checking and savings at Washington Mutual when it failed in 2008.
The FDIC arranged for Chase to take it over. Nobody lost any money, and nobody I know had any problems with checks clearing or withdrawing cash at ATMs or paying their rent or mortgages.
I think the demise of Washington Mutual is still considered the biggest bank failure in US history, it happened while quite a lot of other bad things were happening, yet depositors ended up being totally fine. The systems in place for this are actually really good, and the FDIC is fast and competent.
The FDIC almost always pays insured depositors within a few business days of a closing, usually the next business day. Payment is made either by providing each depositor a new account at another insured institution or by issuing a check to each depositor.
FDIC says SVB customers will have access to insured funds on Monday, so seems like the answer to your question of how long it takes is “next business day”.
No rational reason, however during bank runs rationality tends to go out the window and even banks that are perfectly safe on paper can find themselves in trouble.
FRB wants people to believe the contagion is limited to tech and that they have limited exposure to it, so that folks don’t take deposits out en masse. If people start to think that it’s unstable, then they’ll take money out and it’ll be a death spiral like SVB.