Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
UK Police arrest women’s safety volunteers on coronation day (independent.co.uk)
7 points by jarym on May 8, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments



There are clearly serious concerns about the UK heading into an authoritarian state. The right to protest has been so seriously curtailed that even innocent people who aren't protesting can end up arrested and detained for hours.

Gotta hand it to the US and their Constitution, it definitely does a better (though maybe not perfect) job protecting citizens from government over-reach.


Same is happening in all commonwealth countries.

The US is hardened against some of this, having been born out of rejecting the commonwealth, while others are not and it's showing now.


The US was born out of rejecting royal rule by decree. The "commonwealth" wasn't a thing yet - it was still the empire.

But rejecting arbitrary rule in the form of kings seems to have paid some dividends... as long as you don't look too hard at "executive orders".


The US appears to have much stronger constitutionality granted freedoms than most other countries.

A well functioning liberal democracy needs a means of kicking out the government, and strong limits on the kind of laws a government can impose, through constitutional protections.

Personally I don't think that "decrees" or executive orders or whatever are a problem, as long as they are within the constitution and the population can vote to kick out whoever made them. Much worse is when the constitution, or personal freedoms that should be enshrined, are violated "democratically" with a majority support.


Yeah to me it just looks like the US went from rejecting hereditary kings to having temporary elected kings.


I don't think this shows a direction of travel.

The last proclamation/coronation was a long time ago so most people have no experience but I suspect nothing has changed. These are 'sacred' occasions and public dissent will not be allowed during official events.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: