Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

an easy way to look at the way window 8 seems to treat the desktop is to look at the way windows 7 and previous treat the command line.

There are still many commandline apps, even many important parts of windows require the command line to operate, however microsoft hasnt exactly put a great deal of development time into advancing commandline UI technology (and there are many companies who HAVE done just that)

plainly speaking it seems they are relegating the desktop to be the "next commandline" another relic, however the transition fails to address the fact that at it's current state, metro is not able to replace the desktop for anything but the most basic applications.

another problem mentioned elsewhere ("windows 8 is leaky") can also be explained another way - tablets have touchscreens but no easy way to use a mouse / keyboard, desktops have mouse / keyboard but generally no easy way to use a touchscreen, so using one interaction method pretty much precludes the other and trying to make an interface which works with both creates a mushy middling kind of experience which combines good and BAD things from both methods.we see this when trying to use a mouse with metro apps as well as when trying to use touch with desktop ones.

I'm treating windows 8 as another vista for now (and I used vista for many years) it's usable, full of new ideas, but lacking in that final polish where all the new pieces and old pieces meet.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: