Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> After reddit's hostility towards users became clear

You mean the API thing? For me it was a month earlier when they put my 13-year account into a Kafkaesque shadow-hell.

(TLDR: Randomly shadowbanned as if a spambot, all content removed, appealed, appeal GRANTED with an "oops" apology, but nothing was actually fixed, can't use appeals-page to contact them because it falsely claims my account is normal, I can't private message anybody, weeks of modmail to admins with no reply, etc.)



It says a lot about the state of the reddit codebase when they can't even edit post titles. Likewise the recent deletion of private messages points to a serious lack of talent and really terrible code.

Makes me think that the API works were almost completely due to an inability of reddit's engineers to write anything but the most basic code. And modifying more complex code is right out.


just create a new account and move on?


How unhelpfully dismissive. Even if I was willing to let 13 years of content/memberships/friend-links/etc. be destroyed, do you honestly think I didn't try that?

I resurrected a 6-year-old account I had used as a throwaway, since it already had some qualifying age and karma, allowing me to to actually post in relevant help-subreddits. (For example, I posted a bug-report in /r/bugs.)

Yet within couple weeks, IT HAPPENED AGAIN: Totally vanilla usage leading to the exact same series of events, plunging the other account into the same inexplicable bugged state.


Do you have roommates or other people sharing your Internet connection?

It really, really sucks that reddit messed up your account. I've grown incredibly attached to some of my online personas and I'd be devastated if they were taken from me.

It's like my bewilderment when talking to people who think your comment history should be private. I want people to see who I am, and how I respond to different situations. Even those times when I've made mistakes and jumped to bad conclusions.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: