Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The new branding is recognizable, cute and short. However, Tofu has a somewhat mixed reputation. I guess OpenTofu can stand on its own though.


This didn’t stop Celery, though! Some people don’t like other vegetables either!


Care to explain why?


Tofu has an ancient reputation as a vegetarian replacement for meat. Its taste depends on the preparation (raw Tofu is very flexible).

Some people associate it positively ('ethical', 'wholesome', 'tasty'), others do not ('not the real thing', 'tasteless').


In its original producing country it's often used as an expression of excessive softness ("tofu mental" for instance, for mental fragility). But it's also cute and inoffensive, I think it's a nice name overall.


I think OpenTofu should embrace the negative connotations. Go crazy, make everything Tofu, that's the goal. It'd be a nice side history for marketing purposes. I doubt anyone would not use the tool because of it and others would get a good chuckle.


There’s also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Top-posting which is (or used to be) negatively connotated.


It's a fine name in my estimation! tofu is good stuff, even the most antivegan person has to admit that it's nutritious and healthy


So does terraforming, fwiw.


Is terraforming even a thing outside of the realm of SF? I can't say I've ever seen it depicted as anything but positive, since it's taking unlivable planets and making them livable.


there are countless SF examples where terraforming is used against the protagonist group in some negative manner; some alien race begins some scheme to turn the planet hotter/colder/acidic/whatever and has to be stopped by some hero.

as far as being a thing outside of SF, there are lots of studies on the idea of being able to do it in one way or another to both the moon and Mars, with real life validation efforts here on Earth -- but no real practical efforts as far as I know.

p.s. the reason I avoid mentioning our efforts here on Earth changing the climate being akin to terraforming is that I think that intentionality is really the defining feature of terraforming that differentiates it from pollution or abuse otherwise.


There are plenty of examples of terraforming going/having gone wrong or being abandoned. My first associations are Snowpiercer (overdoing the fight against climate change) and Stellaris (abandoned machinery on planets).


I think this [0] may be what the OP meant.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Plan_for_the_Transform...


Or the global warming. In a few years we'll be able to say that's deliberate if we continue.


In relative terms, co2 emissions have gone up >50% since Kyoto; in absolute terms, we have emitted more co2 since Kyoto than in all of history before.

I'd argue your "in a few years" was like 2018 or 2019 or so.


Yeah, I'm lost.

Terraforming is a sci-fi concept for making planets viable for life......

What's the other usage?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: