Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Astronomical numbers may be large but in e.g. computational science people have been dealing with even larger numbers for quite a while now.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shannon_number



Not wishing to be rude but that's peanuts.

Try http://www.xamuel.com/busy-beaver-numbers/

If anyone can come up with any larger numbers I'd like to hear them.

EDIT: Oh and if you think the universe is big and hard to imagine, try considering the phase space of the entire universe! That's the set of all possible configurations of all the particles. Bananas.

I encourage you to watch this lecture from Roger Penrose, Aeons Before the Big Bang,

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OutKE3tyG94

...if only for the fantastic hand-drawn overhead transparencies in all the colours of the rainbow. They are a delight and I want to see hipster programmers using them at conferences.

BTW also watch it for the crazy physics.


Yes, I know Shannon's number is "small". The point was that it's been around for a while, and that with the right mathematical tools one can deal with such numbers without having their mind boggled.


Fair enough. I clicked on the link expecting to get something like graham's number or TREE(3) or some other monstrosity, and felt kind of cheated when it was only 10^43 ;)

Do those mathematical methods really allow us to comprehend these numbers though? They only really allow use to express them as configurations of other numbers don't they? Even if you understand hyperoperations and stuff you're not really gazing upon what those figures really entail.

I suppose all mathematics involves notation in the end.


Sure, but there is still something to be said for bound finite numbers. The universe is somewhere between 26 billion light years wide and infinity. From what we can observe it might be reasonable to guess that it's smaller than grahm's number of light years wide, but for all our hubris that's still just a reasonable guess.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: