Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> ...bomber incursions into Yemen which of course Egypt has no interest in doing since it could turn into a full hot war pretty easily.

How would the Houthis respond?

Much less, what do they have that can possibly hit Egypt.

That said, bombing might not do the trick. Just create more suffering in Yemen.



Ghadr-110 has a claimed range up to 2000km, which is just about the distance from Sanaa to Cairo

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghadr-110

https://www.mapdevelopers.com/draw-circle-tool.php?circles=%...


> Ghadr-110 has a claimed range up to 2000km

It also seems to have a new place in history. A losing place but still. . .

On November 6, 2023, a Ghadr-110 missile was launched from Yemen by the Houthis towards Israel, which was intercepted by the Arrow-2 system while it was still outside of Earth's atmosphere, in what was described as the first instance of combat in space in human history


This idea of the Houthis as some sort of desert people misses that they took over the military of what was formerly an ally of "The West"..

They have attack helicopters: https://pictures.reuters.com/CS.aspx?VP3=SearchResult&VBID=2..., https://pictures.reuters.com/CS.aspx?VP3=SearchResult&VBID=2...

They have American & Soviet fighter jets (F-5 / SU-22): https://pictures.reuters.com/CS.aspx?VP3=SearchResult&VBID=2..., https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-H4BV3xzWWXk/TnIKIQMOAFI/A...

They have tons of cruise missiles: https://pictures.reuters.com/archive/YEMEN-SECURITY-PARADE-R..., https://pictures.reuters.com/archive/YEMEN-SECURITY-PARADE-R...

And ballistic missiles: https://pictures.reuters.com/archive/YEMEN-SECURITY-PARADE-R...

They're being supplied by Iran and whoever else hates Saudi Arabia, so they have a ton of capability to launch pretty devastating attacks on their neighbors -- hence why we have destroyers and aircraft carriers in the region. The missiles targeting merchant ships are bad -- it'd be worse if they started targeting land-based military targets in other countries.


> They have American & Soviet fighter jets (F-5 / SU-22)

They have, from the accounts I’ve seen (including their own propaganda videos) a single flyable F-5 constituting their entire “fast air combat capability” of those delivered to Yemen more than 40 years ago (and the F-5 was an older cheap export fighter then.)

And... I wouldn't expect it to be flyable much longer. Mobile missile launchers may be hard to find and kill on the ground, boring conventional fixed-wing jet fighters aren't, and even though they aren't the strategic target of the coalition the US has put together, US combat doctrine very heavily favors early destruction of an enemy’s air combat capability and air defenses to maximize freedom of operation.


True enough - but they've carried out multiple strikes with the SU-22s in their possession and can presumably restock / refit those with Iranian support -- they also have several dozen older MIGs. There's no doubt that they'd be annihilated if they tried to use those for continued offensive missions outside of the Yemeni borders but they could likely pull off a single fast attack on Cairo or Suez if they were so inspired.


I would view claims of "several dozen older MIGS" with great suspicion. There's a report of a single MIG-29, but no word of its flying condition. In the civil war, Yemen had to rely upon mercenary pilots to fly them, as well as maintain them.


> but they could likely pull off a single fast attack on Cairo or Suez if they were so inspired.

No. They couldn't. Yemen to either is like three times the range of the SU-22 on a shortest distance path, which would take them through Saudi Arabia and close enough for mistakes of intent to Israel, either of which—as well as Egypt—has Air Forces more than capable of intercepting and destroying them if they magically gained the range to try to pull of that kind of flight.

The Houthi Air Force is useful for their civil war, and not a whole lot else.


They've been targeting land-based military (and industrial) targets in other countries. They've been fighting Saudi Arabia for maybe a decade, using a variety of drones/cruise missiles.

Their air force is a joke though. A single flying F-5 (vintage 1970), and some decrepit SU-22 Fitters with no range.

Also, those aren't "attack" helicopters. They're bog standard Mi-8 transport helicopters. You can use them to attack, but they're nothing like a Hind/Hokum/Havoc or Apache helicopter.


Houthis have long range missiles (courtesy of Iran). They regularly launch them at Israel, they can launch them at Egypt too.


> How would the Houthis respond?

It assumed that Houthi is a proxy of Iran so the question is how Iran would respond.


I thought the Houthis were no longer receiving funding from Iran with the SA-Iran deal of 2023. Did that change?


> I thought the Houthis were no longer receiving funding from Iran with the SA-Iran deal of 2023. Did that change?

I think its more “Iran lied and has used less overt channels” than “that changed”.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: