Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

See: bin Laden's letter to America doing rounds in the internet in 2023.



False equivalency. Most people like living in America and tons of people want to move there, while only religious fanatics would be okay living in a country built and controlled by Al-qaeda


> Bad entities can point out when other entities behave badly. You don't have to like either of them.

> See: bin Laden's letter to America doing rounds in the internet in 2023.

> False equivalency. Most people like living in America and tons of people want to move there, while only religious fanatics would be okay living in a country built and controlled by Al-qaeda

Without question, the comparison is equivalent. Portraying it as either-or is ignoring the root sentiment of "everyone has faults", regardless of who you think is superior in an example.


Our religious fanatics have put an insurrectionist who stole classified documents as their top choice for leader. Hopefully the trend of being a desirable place to live continues, but I don't know if it's yet safe to point fingers at the awful governments built by other sets of religious fanatics.


the assumption is that Trump was only elected by Christians?

I honestly feel bad for the left. Given everything their news media tells them is under threat they seem legitimately scared about a nonissue. The power of the news cycle.


I'm sure any number of Christian lunatics would love to remake America into Y'all-Qaeda.


I’m guessing you don’t know much about religion?

Christianity and islam are quite a bit different, the latter literally convinving people to convert by sword.

And here I thought HN got rid of bigoted comments like this.


> the latter literally convinving people to convert by sword

Unlike such famously gentle Christian coercions like the Spanish Inquisition or the Crusades. :P


That was Catholicism, not Christianity.

Which is my point, your average non-religious person does not understand the difference between religions. Be it Islam vs Christianity, or Christianity vs Catholicism.


Wow.

If you're going to tar all of Islam by their worst members ("the latter literally convinving people to convert by sword"), you can't object if someone applies the same logic to Christianity.

> Christianity vs Catholicism

Catholics aren't Christian? Sounds exactly like some of evangelical nuts I grew up around. Most of the world views Christianity as a big umbrella, with Catholics and Protestants being two of the major flavors. (Somehow I highly doubt you're Eastern Orthodox.)

> your average non-religious person does not understand the difference between religions

And apparently, neither do you, my evangelical wingnut in Christ.


If you take out Israel-bashing and add a bit of fiscal cuts in, it very much reads like R-party’s agenda.

But that’s just me, being European and grandstanding on the orange website.


You can take your classist “Y’all Qaeda” and shove it. If you want to critique politics that’s fine, but please understand what you’re spewing is dehumanizing propaganda implying more than half of the country are dumb hicks.


Well, bless your heart! I guess a hit dog really will holler.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: