Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The world's first non-repairable car.

Apple's phones have about 7 years of first-party support / guaranteed useful life, compared with the rest of the industry's standard of maybe 2. Yeah I'd never buy a car that will only be good for 7 years, but let's see what they ship.



I'm pretty sure there is no such "guarantee". You can definitely Apple has a track record of supporting 7 years and I have absolutely no problem with that. Samsung and Google actually say they are committed to 7 years of support for the latest phones in their official document.

Also the rest of the industry is not 2. 3 years is very common these days for phones, 5 getting more common. And for computers... Many business computers are supported for a long time, and Windows is famous for its backwards compatibility and support (Windows 10 is supported till 2025, 10 years from its release).


Check out my reply to a sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39115135

Yes, I speculate and draw my conclusions based on my most recent experience (2017-2019) with Android. I'm glad it's improving, but I'm not in a hurry to "experience" Android again.


The batteries don't have 7 years of useful life, though. And replacing them is made intentionally difficult to encourage people to just upgrade instead.

A lot of people don't live near an Apple store, and few people are prepared to be without their phone while mailing it off for a battery swap.


It is fairly trivial. I had the battery replaced in various iPhones and it costs like 70€. Any phone repair shop can do it.


Not for much longer if Apple has their way -- they've been pioneering "parts pairing", which would kill third-party repair: https://www.ifixit.com/News/69320/how-parts-pairing-kills-in...


They have a program for independent repair companies. It doesn't pass Louis Rossmann's bar since it doesn't let him do board-level repair, but none of the "fix your screen/replace your battery" shops I've ever seen do that anyway, so it would be fine for them.


The program is still BS, and was only even done solely to head off Right-to-Repair legislation which was not going Apple's way.

Board-level repair is pretty crucial for data recovery when the hardware manufacturer insists on soldering the solid-state storage to the motherboard.


Fortunately in the US they'll be required to offer a minimum battery warranty of 8 years


Yes, Apple deserves some credit for being early to it but now Google and Samsung offer 7 year support for their newer phones too.


That's really good news. Is this for all Samsung models currently sold or just the flagship? I can't find much on the internet


> Yeah I'd never buy a car that will only be good for 7 years

But a lot of people would. There are many people who trade their car after 4-5 years, or turn it back in at the end of the lease.


Well, I'm yet to buy a car in my life (viva la public transport), so there's a realistic chance I don't know what I'm talking about, but I can imagine the 4-5 years cycle largely depends on the resale value.

Apple products can have a hit&miss resale value; I think the 2015-2019 line of MacBooks were bad value at any time and any price point, and will be avoided well into the future. Hence my speculation: let's see what they ship this time.


A lot of the time, the only thing that many car buyers worry about is the monthy payment.

They'll trade in their old car on a new one and if the payment works in their budget they're happy. They don't really care about values.


Well I guess that's one reason why I seem to be incompatible with car ownership. When COVID hit, I continued to pay for my public transport ticket even while I couldn't even use it, because I wanted to throw in my share towards keeping the system alive and as good as it is.


> compared with the rest of the industry's standard of maybe 2.

You're just making up facts to protect your beloved brand/cult. C'mon. All my non-Mac computers I'm using here have been around way longer than two years.


You're talking about different things. Apple officially supports / provides software updates for its iPhones for 7 years. Other phone manufacturers' durations of support vary, but they're usually much less. Until fairly recently, Google provided 3 years of software updates for Pixels, for example. [1]

[1] https://www.androidauthority.com/phone-update-policies-16586...


Samsung accounts for the vast majority of Android phones in actual use. Their current policy is also 7 years, as is Google's. You're right that historically this was different, but things change.


> You're just making up facts [...]

Here's objective facts and my experiences that I used to draw my conclusions.

My final Android phones were: [1] a Samsung A7 (2017), which included a non-replaceable battery, shipped with Android 6 (2015), officially supported Android 8 (2017; theoretical first-party security patches which it never received were offered until 2021), no longer receives updates even from LineageOS, and never ran postmarketOS; and [2] a Nokia 3 (2017), which had pretty much the same story (support ended on Android 9).

In 2019, someone gave me an old, smashed [3] iPhone 7 (2016), and the phone literally worked better than any Android phone I've owned before, including either of the two above. Since it was already physically falling apart, I took the liberty of getting [4] an iPhone SE (2020), which is still with me; the 7 continued to serve in the family for a couple more years.

[1]: https://www.gsmarena.com/samsung_galaxy_a7_(2017)-8335.php

[2]: https://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_3-8572.php

[3]: https://www.gsmarena.com/apple_iphone_7-8064.php

[4]: https://www.gsmarena.com/apple_iphone_se_(2020)-10170.php

> All my non-Mac computers I'm using here have been around way longer than two years.

I have a 2002 TiBook, which, believe me or not, continues to outlive my T61 and X200. My MBP (2017) had a spicy pillow though (which Apple repaired for free, outside of warranty).

> [...] to protect your beloved brand/cult.

I'm not a cultist, I'm a pragmatist. I used to believe in things - I had a [5] Jolla (2013) for the longest time, because I believed in Free Software and Open Source and all that stuff, until I realized suffering for your values is not necessarily the healthiest thing to do, and that freedom is not strictly a function of a software license, but of things the hardware+software enables you to do with it.

[5]: https://www.gsmarena.com/jolla_jolla-review-1025.php


You refer to your smart phone as a non-mac computer? Because nobody is talking about Mac's besides you. Or PC's. Or "computers" outside of smart phones in general.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: