Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

DMARC reports are not good for "keep an eye on who is spoofing my domain and then take action on it." But what they ARE good for is finding gaps in your DMARC policy. Like "oops, I forgot to add the helpdesk ticketing system to the policy" or "huh, it looks like the marketing department started using a new email provider, and they're not covered by the policy."

In other words, it's useful for spotting legitimate stuff that's accidentally failing, not for doing anything with the unauthorized stuff.

For a personal domain that only one or two people use, this is less likely to be worth bothering with.




I get reports showing attempts at least one a month per domain, a few in a week trying root and then subdomains. So I do like the fact that I know the policy I have implemented is useful. I do wish, however, that there was more useful information in the reports and that a variation of forensic reporting was more of a thing.

But you're spot on with finding gaps. It's basically the premise for every commercial DMARC product on the market. It's also crazy to see how companies blindly trust and never remediate senders from having access to corporate domains.

I'll, however, disagree with regard to personal domains. It's not hard. Do it. Everyone who helps clean up these things makes a small difference. If you own your own domain and are leveraging email this should be table stakes. I have recommended MailHardener [0] (no affiliation) in the past for their fantastic documentation around SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI, etc - but also they have a free tier of one domain and they provide a grade with respect to your posture. It's really simple, and people I know have used it to learn how to implement these configurations on a broader scale.

[0] https://www.mailhardener.com/


I have definitely done it for my personal domains and I agree that it's not particularly hard. I just meant that for my personal domains I have not found the reports as useful as I do in business contexts, because I am the only person sending mail from those domains and it's (mostly) unlikely that I'd spin up a new source and forget to add it to the DMARC policy.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: