Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> How do those of you who feel so strongly about this ad get through daily life?

Whilst I didn't feel a great deal watching the video, this statement is very presumptive.

Reversed: How does one get through daily life _not_ feeling so strongly about things?

Should perhaps we, those who didn't feel a great deal here, not reflect on whether we might be feeling as much of life as we could, empathise more deeply, care about broader things, consider life as more than ration or reason?

It didn't bother me one way or another, but I also didn't assume anything. I can imagine a life far more rich just by feeling more, seeing more colours in the same palette, tasting more when eating food, and feeling so much more when just experiencing life... perhaps for all the benefit of feeling more, there's just the sharper edge that sometimes you feel more about something like an Apple advert.




> Reversed: How does one get through daily life _not_ feeling so strongly about things?

You didn’t reverse the question. No one is advocating not having strong feelings about anything. The correct reverse would be “how do those of you who don’t feel strongly about this ad get through daily life?”.

The answer to that is “by not entering a state of frenzied stress about every inconsequential thing and being mindful of the battles worth fighting”. There is a finite amount of things you can feel strongly for in your life, and I do think this ad is incredibly minor.

No one is going to remember or talk about this in a week, regardless of if Apple had apologised or not. If only we could’ve had all this outrage and media attention about something which truly matters and is urgent to all humans (like, say, climate change) that would’ve been swell. Now that would’ve been empathetic, shown a care about broader things, and be considerate of life.


There's plenty of outrage over climate change. It's not clear it meaningfully contributes to solving the problem.


>How does one get through daily life _not_ feeling so strongly about things?

I feel strongly about important things, not all things.


Many people (and I’m one of those people) feel that the preservation of craftsmanship and human created art/music is extremely important to a healthy society.


Every object in that video was mass produced rubbish so craftsmanship survived unharmed.


Many musical instruments are still made by hand to this day. Many of the cameras still in active use were too.

And even if you pick up a crappy starter guitar, learning it is a purely human endeavor, propagating the mastery that has been passed down through generations.

And I have no idea how to reconcile “it’s all mass produced rubbish” with “craftsmanship survived unharmed”. These are in direct conflict.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: