Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Low density UIs were a scourge before mobile. There has always been a kind of designer who privileges "negative space" over everything else and can't imagine any greater luxury than having a 27" screen and devoting 26" of it to whitespace.



Famously derided in the seminal work "The visual display of quantitative information". There they give the thought experiment: weigh the ink on your page devoted to data points, compare it to the entire rest of the ink. You want the largest ratio possible.


Tufte is famous for his opposition to wasteful use of ink, or "chartjunk"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chartjunk

which relates to a strong preference to use whitespace as a tool for visual organization. If you could separate two areas of the plot by drawing a line with them, Tufte would have you use whitespace instead.

Tufte certainly loves complex charts based on complex data, drawn as economically as possible. He'd also recognize that there's a time for a simple chart based on simple data and that such a chart should be as simple as possible: if you want to make a bar chart with Excel with the last 12 quarters of revenue for your business for instance he'd accept that, but insist that you turn off as much chartjunk as you can.


Wouldn't a low-density UI yield an infinitely large ratio?

   Not Much Ink / Nothing else.


If the 'nothing else' is blank paper. Any background, it's Not Much Ink / Entire Page Of Ink


I think about this every time I browse a web site, and the text is this tiny, 5" wide strip down the center, leaving 10" of empty, useless whitespace on both sides. Thanks, designer. I'm glad I bought a 27" monitor for this shit.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: