Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The tip does NOT work in general. Afaik (currently) the majority of ATS do not work like that. There is no simple ChatGPT auto advance application feature.

The biggest ATS do care about AI and privacy regulations which make this approach legally problematic.

Regarding the EU: if the ATS does NOT list OpenAI as a data subprocessor you can expect they wont send a resume to ChatGPT. They are not allowed to.



The ATS will not but the recruiter might make themselves more efficient by uploading stuff to chatgpt.


They would get less efficient if they did.

Recruiters need/want to decide in less than 30 seconds. It is easier for them to just make a rough call after looking at the resume from a distance


Really depends on if the recruiter knows anything about what they are recruiting for or not.

Recruiter focused on a small area of tech and has hired for similar roles for several years? They probably understand at least what to look for on a resume.

Recruiter has 30+ roles to recruiter for spanning marketing, tech, and finance? They also had exactly 1 conversation with the manager about what they are looking for? They don't know JavaScript from Java? ChatGPT is going to at least give them a, "Call this person" or "Dont call this person" response.

source: was a tech recruiter for many years before becoming a developer


oh dear, most recruiters are clueless, and they WILL reject a candidate who is a core React contributor, because unfortunately they don't know JavaScript

i have worked now in the industry for a few years. it is sad.


a lot of recruiters are very bad at their jobs, honestly it's my experience that most of them are very bad at their jobs.


They are! We are. Well over 90% of us.

Unless you specialize and understand a distinct vertical all recruiters are pointless.

I say this as someone who has done it very successfully for 20 years, pre-brain tumor (I’ve commented on this in the past).

I’m coming back soon and expect to be as successful again because I understand people and I understand my market. I’m a failed dev. Not quite smart enough to be one, but more than smart enough to help hire ‘em.

I’ve literally had that react / JavaScript thing happen from the thread above with a corporate recruiter I knew.

Arrogance mixed with ignorance as well as only knowing a boom market your whole career is a powerful combination boost to incompetence!


I dunno what the interface looks like, but couldn't they hand the AI the entire stack of resumes and tell it to give them the N best ones?


too complex.

all the ATS (=recruiting softwares) are not built for that

think about it: they typically support looking at one resume at a time, then click a yes/no button, then show the next one

it is not easy to use OpenAI as you mentioned. many problems. one is: you will need to search/scroll for those resumes which the AI selected


Not if the recruiter needs to deal with thousands upon thousands of auto generated CVs


Plausible but still a GDPR violation.


Not erasing your emails after some time (or at least not removing the sender or recipient email address) is also a GDPR violation (because email addresses are personal information).

Source: a privacy compliance lawyer working at a billion dollar European corporation told me that one day.


That would make sense only if the owner of that address is not an ongoing customer of yours


It's for as long as necessary to serve the purpose. If you're brought to court, you could either argue that you still need it for your specific use case, or you can point to some internal procedure to delete stuff that's way past the point of usefulness and say that you're already complying.

And as the parent comment said, you don't really have to delete them at all, keeping some sort of a copy that you ran through some sort of a personal data removal tool also works.

Example: years old closed support tickets, you'll never need to know exactly who made them, but you might wanna reference some info from them.


But an ongoing customer would have newer emails that don’t get deleted over time.


I know about at least one big world wide corp that use LLM for checking CVs, I'm not sure if something like that would actually change result (mostly because this is multi prompt chain) but it's definitely used/considered by many companies

you cannot use chatgpt, but you can use azure openai API (with is basically the same thing, but because it's hosted solution, its allowed to be used)


True, and for the bigger companies you can assume this will be handled correctly. A lot of smaller companies don’t follow the rules that strictly.

Off-topic: if I understand the GDPR correctly, applicants can also request all of their data of the interview process, and the company will have to send their interview notes, assessments etc. Would be a dick move, and I’ve never seen it done, but I’m still waiting for the first candidate to try it.


If true, that would be a good way to get around companies never telling you why you were rejected. I'm doubtful that would actually work though.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: