Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

2c,

1) Don’t read the news. It IS optional. Personally, if there were a good reason to read it, it would be based on curiosity and interest in knowing about humanity at large.

2) someone should be reading the news, because of economics, politics, and voting.

In the current global economy - your fate is dependent on the fate and actions of others.

The actions of Russia have hampered economies in the EU. This has currently obscured the strength of the underlying EU economy, making the US economy appear stronger.

Simultaneously, Italy, which had a lower dependency on Russian energy, is doing better and hopefully reducing some of its loan burden.

That’s just… fun to know?

Sheikh Hasina’s government in Bangladesh collapsed, the interim / caretaker government which has come in is headed by a Nobel Laureate. Their mandate is to prepare for another round of elections.

They don’t call themselves ministers, but advisors (iirc). I thought that was an interesting wrinkle and potential counter example for discussions on government, which happen regularly.

I don’t know how to frame my point better, but it does feel that this comment thread presupposes only a few narrow options.

Perhaps breaking from news is good when it’s just overwhelmingly negative, and designed to harm you?

But perhaps its great when its a way to address your interest and curiosity ?




Then funny part “stronger US economy” has stock crash not related in any way to events in Ukraine or Middle East. It crashed because finance guys had scheme borrowing Japanese currency and buying stocks with it.

So it is always that you might have illusion of knowing what is going on.

I love talking heads “experts” making assumptions but it is just talking and real stuff is always deeper.

So I rather people voting on their core values whatever those are than “perceived wisdom they are so informed”.


I mean, there isnt any illusion, because the stock market != economy. The statement was about economies.

Secondly - that was an incredibly short paragraph, so talking about illusions, and depth is *really* assuming a lot from under 250 words.

Plus your addition of current events, only underscored the point of needing to be aware of the news. So... thanks?

> So I rather people voting on their core values whatever those are than “perceived wisdom they are so informed”.

I think this assertion was not supported (and potentially undermined) by your supporting anecdotes.

Edit: if anything, your sharing more News to .. argue (?) against the position, supports the point that aware of current affairs is needed.


Hey we are discussing things so I am not about scoring points here ;)

I might write in confrontational tone and I like to write opposing view just for discussion sake.

I do agree market != economy. I think “perceived wisdom they are so informed” is still quite a good statement.


Ah, thanks for highlighting that. Tone can be quite a painn


> … That’s just… fun to know?

I agree, I like to read these analyses too but I don’t think they’re “news”, they’re usually in a wonky blog I follow.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: