That cars are such a slow mover is the reason that we need to focus on it now, rather than later.
I don't think you hypothetical would change even a tiny fraction of phone replacements, but even if it did, legislative bandwidth in the US is extremely low and should be reserved for the high impact changes. Anything that distracts from the must-do messages is quite likely to be harmful.
We make people jump through all sorts of hoops for plastic straws and plastic bags that have approximately zero environmental win compared to far smaller changes to their car use.
The real problem is the social attitude that cars can not be touched or criticized. That needs to start changing.
Our phones are not the core of climate change, our cars and all the massive environmental damage from mining the necessary minerals for them really are.
I don't think you hypothetical would change even a tiny fraction of phone replacements, but even if it did, legislative bandwidth in the US is extremely low and should be reserved for the high impact changes. Anything that distracts from the must-do messages is quite likely to be harmful.
We make people jump through all sorts of hoops for plastic straws and plastic bags that have approximately zero environmental win compared to far smaller changes to their car use.
The real problem is the social attitude that cars can not be touched or criticized. That needs to start changing.
Our phones are not the core of climate change, our cars and all the massive environmental damage from mining the necessary minerals for them really are.