Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't get why other phones don't do this. Is it complicated? I think it just plays a recorded voice greeting. It's simpler than a answering machine. There is no fancy AI or anything like that.



Doesn't it involve sending the phone number that calls you to an online service? I can imagine that has big privacy implications.


What is a privacy implication when literal spam farms already know everything about you?


Telcos already keep this information and Google having it as well doesn't really change much. Both are going to sell it plus give it up to law enforcement when asked.


It doesn't play any kind of greeter. Seems to be an online database of spam numbers, I receive calls marked as Spam with a big red exclamation mark. it's not as simple as blocking any calls that aren't already contacts. I could never use that professionally.


I'm talking about "automated call screening feature"

https://support.google.com/phoneapp/answer/9118387?hl=en

> Call Assist answers the call and asks who's calling and why


iPhones also have the ability to block unknown callers.


My Nokia 3310 could do that. This actually answers the call and asks the caller what they want, it then rings if the call seems legit.


How did that work?


It simply rejected calls that lacked caller ID, which is what I assume the GP meant by unknown callers. It wasn't only Nokia either, every single phone that I have ever owned has been able to do this. Its right there alongside novel features such as "sending a text" or "making a phone call."

If you meant the Pixel feature then there are probably lots of videos and posts covering it.


> This actually answers the call and asks the caller what they want, it then rings if the call seems legit.

I thought you meant you could do that on your OG 3310 so I was curious.


Plus you can get apps with caller lists.

I have one from Verizon since they are my carrier. For free it does an amazing job blocking spam calls. If I was willing to pay (I’m not) it would tell me what kind of spam call it is.

Not worth the price.

I still don’t answer calls unless they’re in my address book or I’m expecting one. But I get very very few calls anyway thanks to the app.

And they are allowed to leave voicemails, which they never do. Real callers do if I get an unexpected genuine call.

Add in the features iOS has had in the last few releases to be able to see transcriptions of voicemails, now live as they’re being left, and most of the hassle is gone.

The spammers trained everyone to stop answering. I shouldn’t have to do any of this. But it’s better than it was a few years ago.

Text is the new spam hell for me.


> iOS has had in the last few releases to be able to see transcriptions of voicemails

Never saw that


It’s had it for a few years for messages already left.

I think iOS 17 (last September) was when they added live transcription as it was being left in the lock screen if you press the icon to see it.

Or maybe it was 18 this September.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: