Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because the conclusion is not workable.

Almost every single app today interacts with the network in some way.

You would be constantly annoying the user with prompt after prompt if you wanted to get consent for sending any relatively harmless data off the device.



It's telling that Android, for example, has all sorts of granular permissions you can set for an app, but "Network Access" is not one of them.

My Calculator app does not need to call home.

A good portion of the apps I use fall into this category, and a straightforward mechanism to opt them out of access would be welcome.


FWIW, a "Network Access" app permission is one of the features that GrapheneOS provides. It is only setting offered to the user every single app install. It should be in base AOSP, and I have to wonder why it isn't already.


Ah the GDPR complaint. Just don't collect the data and you won't be annoying anyone!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: