Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> most dog breeds have been bred primarily for a specific practical purpose

Sure. But most of those traits are shallow. Let the breed go stray and many characteristics go away. The neoteny does not.

> Not necessarily exactly cuteness

The neoteny—large eyes and heads, for example—is precisely cuteness. Not all breeds are equally neotenic. But they’re very much not wolves.



> Sure. But most of those traits are shallow. Let the breed go stray and many characteristics go away.

A lot of characteristics seem to be bred in and instinctive - breed specific behaviour occurs without training. Strays do not breed pure so of course breed specific characteristics are lost.

> The neoteny—large eyes and heads, for example—is precisely cuteness

To an extent yes. The specific trait mentioned in the comment I was replying to was not neotenous. Not all neotonous traits are physically cute.


> breed specific behaviour occurs without training. Strays do not breed pure so of course breed specific characteristics are lost

My point is neoteny almost isn’t breed specific. Let strays breed and it’s preserved—stray dogs are cuter than wolves.

Wild dogs don’t become wolves. (They also stop being French bulldogs.)

> Not all neotonous traits are physically cute

Almost all physically-cute traits are neutenous.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: