Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Why should I pay for your TSA Precheck?

Are you really complaining about spending $70 once every five years to give me TSA Precheck? You won't even notice paying for my Precheck.

Why should I pay for your usage of the TSA? Why not have all $7.55B entirely funded by direct user fees, handing the TSA agents cash or tap a credit card while you go through the scanner? Why should I pay for your airports (often constructed with massive tax subsidies and grants)? Why should I pay for the highways you drive on to go to your airport?

> we are only talking about taking your shoes off and belt.

No, we're also talking about stereoscopic facial scans, high resolution millimeter wave scans of my body, yet another centralized government database tracking my movements, having to showcase all my valuables to all the other passersby by dumping all the electronics out of my bag, wasting my time, wasting our tax dollars, for pretty much no benefit. Ooh but I can skip the line if I surrender more biometrics and pay extra! How nice!



> Why should I pay for your usage of the TSA

You don’t. A tax is added on to every airline ticket I buy.

> Why should I pay for your airports (often constructed with massive tax subsidies and grants)?

Airports make the city money

https://online.fit.edu/degrees/undergraduate/aviation-manage...

> Why should I pay for the highways you drive on to go to your airport?

Airports make money from parking and many charge a surcharge to ride share companies.

> No, we're also talking about stereoscopic facial scans, high resolution millimeter wave scans of my body

You still have to go through the same scanners with TSA Precheck

> yet another centralized government database tracking my movements

If that’s your concern, why would you want TSA Precheck where you have to give the government your fingerprints and go through a background check?

And the airline already knows you are on the plane. They check ID when you check in.

> wasting my time, wasting our tax dollars, for pretty much no benefit

Not getting blown out the sky is a pretty big benefit.

You know you don’t have to y if you don’t want to.


> If that’s your concern, why would you want TSA Precheck where you have to give the government your fingerprints and go through a background check?

I'd rather just have practically none of it because it's largely a waste of money and time and a major inconvenience while providing practically little real security.

> Not getting blown out the sky is a pretty big benefit.

Tons of other countries have far more basic security at airports. They're not constantly having planes blown out of the sky. Airlines operated for decades before the formation of the TSA and millimeter wave scanners and taking off our shoes and stereoscopic face scans and yet they were not getting blown out of the sky.


Metal detectors were common since the 1970s. There were plenty of hijackings and a few bombings before then.

Also technology improved that the terrorist had.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: