Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

When would it kick in, do you think?

Would you need a JSON loisence? A bash loisence? Is Javascript ok but only in the browser, and only under 500 lines?

At what point does the bobby say Oi! ?



How about direct control of human lives?

Therac-25.

Toyota unintended acceleration.

Tesla full self crashing.

Tesla software locks trapping people in lithium fires.


Cars and medical equipment are already heavily regulated.


We're not talking about regulation, but directly responsible professional software engineer licensing.

The federal government classifies most software people as a computer specialist, not an engineer.


We had it. Nobody cared. https://www.nspe.org/career-growth/pe-magazine/may-2018/ncee...

    > The Software Engineering PE exam, which has struggled to reach an audience, will be discontinued by the National Council of Examiners for Engineering and Surveying after the April 2019 administration. The exam has been administered five times, with a total of 81 candidates.

    > NCEES’s Committee on Examination Policy and Procedures reviews the history of any exam with fewer than 50 total first-time examinees in two consecutive administrations and makes recommendations to the NCEES Board of Directors about the feasibility of continuing the exam.
Part of it was "most software developers don't have enough experience in other engineering disciplines to be able to pass the FE exam"

    > This collaboration was preceded by Texas becoming the first state to license software engineers in 1998. The Texas Board of Professional Engineers ended the experience-only path to software engineering licensure in 2006; before the 2013 introduction of the software engineering PE exam, licensure candidates had to take an exam in another discipline.

    > NCEES Director of Exam Services Tim Miller, P.E., says there was a lot of discussion about the exam’s impact, including how many people with software engineering degrees were taking the FE exam. “If they’re not even taking the FE exam, they’re probably not going to take the PE exam,” he says. “In addition, if the boards aren’t regulating the [software engineering profession], it’s tough to get people to take the exam.”


I looked into it after I met the experience requirements. Passed the FE in college.

But there was zero demand for software PE at the time.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: