Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> It's not just to prevent applications to read other applications files, but also to firewall each application individually

Why would one want to prevent applications from reading other applications' files?

We're talking about running desktop applications designed for an OS that isn't built around any concept of application isolation, and for which using a common filesystem is a primary mechanism of interoperability.




> Why would one want to prevent applications from reading other applications' files?

Because I can, and because I don't trust Windows application to be secure.

Thanks to that, I have no problem running 15 year old office software: even if I knew it was malicious, I also know there's nothing it can do without network access, without file access, and with resources constrains (so it can't even cause a denial of service, except to itself).

In the worst case, I guess it could try to erase its own files? (but it would then be restored from an image on the next run, and I would keep going)


> I have no problem running 15 year old office software: even if I knew it was malicious, I also know there's nothing it can do without network access, without file access

Great. Except... WTF can you do with an office application that can't read or write files?




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: