Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There is an enemy, there are raids on civilians and due process has been abandoned.

The military are now being used for police work, and the police are behaving like the military.

This mob are creeping towards KristallMethNacht.



As bad as Trump is, Hitler was packing his political opponents in a concentration camp within month of taking power. It really isn't comparable yet.

But also, he doesn't need to be literally Hitler to be bad.


I know that CECOT is not nearly as bad as concentration camps, but at the same time it's not like Trump refrains from sending people off to camps, based on loose accusations.

What I'm trying to say, or I guess repeat after you, is that fascism doesn't have to be Hitlerian to be fascism. Or in other words, at this point it's too late anyways.

We absolutely should start comparing and measuring now, because at the point where the comparisons match 100%, too much damage will have been done.

If I was religious I'd probably pray for the US, as I'm not I'm just shaking my head in astonishment.


Trump isn't sending his political opponents to camps (yet), is my point. If you're a citizen currently in US, you can, to paraphrase the old Soviet joke, stand next to the White House and shout "Trump is an asshole", and you won't find yourself on a deportation flight tomorrow. OTOH Nazis started creating concentration camps specifically for communists and dissident journalists less than a month after their electoral victory.

I think that focusing on broad comparisons is not the best idea precisely because it's way too easy to deconstruct, and "X is literally Hitler" is such an overused political trope that most people stop listening right away regardless of how much truth there is to it. It's better to focus on the specific negative actions.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: