Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

As someone outside the US, I find this strange. You have a democratically elected president, elected in part on a platform of removing illegal immigrants. He is now removing illegal immigrants. That is democracy at work, is it not?


The presidency is only legally afforded some powers. The issue here isn't Trump's fulfilling of campaign promises. The issue here is if Trump is following the law while doing so.


This is well out of my area of expertise, but isn't illegal immigration a federal issue, and the federal agencies answer to the executive branch?

My understanding of the protests is they're primarily against the removal of illegal immigrants and as Trump has taken control of (?) some state elements that has become a contentious point, but wasn't to begin with.

Normally I'd read up more before discussing with people, but the news article seem pretty blurry on the primary intentions of the protesters and what specifically they are against.


Every immigrant being destined by ICE isn't necessarily an "illegal" immigrant.


Can you provide examples? I'm finding it difficult to seach the news due to the wording picked by media.


They are against the ICE raids and in particular the egregious ones on restaurants, farms, schools, houses of worship, etc.

Indiscriminate rounding up. We are seeing citizens detained. Families separated. Fear, which is clearly the point.


But it's not indiscriminate. It's people who entered the country illegally.

Genuine question here, do you think illegal immigrants in churches or working on farms should not be deported, but those without a job or day labouring should?

I find it strange to distingush an illegal immigrant based on perceived value. If someone breaks into my house but also does my washing and mows my lawn, that doesn't change the fact they broke into my house.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: