Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

And what if the jews set up shop in your living room? What would you say to that?


What if the Arab states stole property multiple times the size of Israel from Mizrahi Jews? Which they did.

The Arab states clearly owe Israelis more reparations than the other way around.


If a genocide survivor showed up on my doorstep with nowhere else to go, I hope that my reaction would be: Welcome fellow man. You must be desperate. How can I help.


[flagged]


Why do you feel the need to lash out at a stranger for expressing love for humans in need?

Do you have some life experience you would be willing to share that could help me understand why my desire to help people in the ways that I can elicits such a response?

I would like to understand.


Your "desire to help people" seems to consist of giving away things that don't belong to you. If you restricted your helping to giving up things of your own it would be laudable, when you sacrifice things that aren't yours to begin with it's the opposite.


But I don’t think I said anything like that. You asked if I would be willing to offer my own home and personal property to refugees and I said yes.

Now you are saying that I offered something that wasn’t mine to give. And that I should be condemned for it. I promise you, my living room is mine, and it is open to those who need it.

I really feel that you are not understanding me (hopefully), or that alternatively you are misinterpreting my words intentionally.

I didn’t volunteer anyone else’s home. I volunteered mine.

I’m not talking about moving an entire continents worth of genocide survivors to occupied land that I don’t control because I wasn’t asked about that. I wasn’t asked about what o would do if those people set up a system that perpetuated a new human tragedy. That seems to be what you want to engage on, but I haven’t said anything about that, I have only had related statements extended in ways that simply do not represent me or anything I have said to you.

I wanted to have an honest and open discussion, but that doesn’t seem to align with your actions and words. The world is better when we assume good intent instead of ill (it’s the only reason I keep engaging with you to be honest). If you want to do that, please engage with the words I have spoken, not the words or intent I haven’t expressed. Alternatively, if you want to keep attributing to me things I haven’t said and breaking the rules of discourse for HN, please stop.


>I'm not talking about moving an entire continents worth of genocide survivors to occupied land that I don’t control because I wasn’t asked about that.

That was certainly the topic of discussion.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: