Tech and product are just small components in what makes the business profitable. And often not as central as we in our industry might _like_ to believe. From my perspective, building software is the easy, the fun part. Many bets made have nothing to do with the software.
And yes, there is enshittification, there is immoral actors. The market doesn't solve these problems, if anything, it causes them.
What can solve them? I have only two ideas:
1. Regulation. To a large degree this stops some of the worst behaviour of companies, but the reality in most countries I can think of is that it's too slow, and too corrupt (not necessarily by accepting bribes, also by wanting to be "an AI hub" or stuff like that) to be truly effective.
2. Professional ethics. This appears to work reasonably well in medicine and some other fields, but I have little hope our field is going to make strides here any time soon. People who have professional ethics either learn to turn it off selectively, or burn out. If you're a shady company, as long as you have money, you will find competent developers. If you're not a shady company, you're playing with a handicap.
It's not all so black and white for sure, so I agree with you that there's _some_ power in choosing who to work for. They'll always find talent if they pay enough, but no need to make it all too easy for them.
And yes, there is enshittification, there is immoral actors. The market doesn't solve these problems, if anything, it causes them.
What can solve them? I have only two ideas:
1. Regulation. To a large degree this stops some of the worst behaviour of companies, but the reality in most countries I can think of is that it's too slow, and too corrupt (not necessarily by accepting bribes, also by wanting to be "an AI hub" or stuff like that) to be truly effective.
2. Professional ethics. This appears to work reasonably well in medicine and some other fields, but I have little hope our field is going to make strides here any time soon. People who have professional ethics either learn to turn it off selectively, or burn out. If you're a shady company, as long as you have money, you will find competent developers. If you're not a shady company, you're playing with a handicap.
It's not all so black and white for sure, so I agree with you that there's _some_ power in choosing who to work for. They'll always find talent if they pay enough, but no need to make it all too easy for them.