Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I am hoping that this is the thing that triggers Matter/Thread to go mainstream.

I'm currently blocked because Google and Amazon don't support "Generic Switches". Which means that if I switch over a light-bulb to being a smart one I can't use something like the Arre Smart Button to control them. Which seems like such a standard requirement that I do not understand why it's not supported.

If Ikea will let me set that up then I'll be delighted.



I'm not sure what I am missing, but isn't it completely possible to connect any kind of smart button to control a light bulb? Isn't this exactly what home assistant is being used for? I only tried it, but was able to add a generic smart button to HA and let it control a USB switch with some led lights. How is your use case different?

UPDATE: Ok, is this about the state of Matter implementation? I think I misunderstood that.


For how much hype Matter had (I remember everyone saying "Just wait! Any day now!") it sure... hasn't delivered


Yeah.

I've got it up and running with some Nanoleaf lights and Amazon Echo running as border routers, and it's rock solid nowadays. But my wife hates voice-controlled devices, so I can't put them in elsewhere until I can slap in some buttons to control them. And that's basically not supported, which leaves me thinking that either the spec is a disaster or Google/Amazon are deliberately kneecapping it.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: