Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Everyone has their own way of measuring quality.

Mine is that a Billy bookcase that I bought from Ikea 25 years ago is must stronger and more stable than a Billy bookcase I bought from Ikea 5 years ago.

And, when looking at what Ikea is selling in 2025 as a Billy bookcase, it's worse yet again.

But, with the cost of living increasing, companies have to cut corners to keep pricing down.

I wonder where the inflection point is where used items become more valuable than the new items being made at current quality levels, including degradation due to age.



It's ironic to use Ikea as an example.

When Ikea first expanded beyond Scandinavia, it was the 'fast fashion' of furniture: beautiful design, but sometimes made of particleboard or polyurethane foam.

There's nothing unusual about that today.


You could have bought a Besta or Hemmes bookshelf, accounting for inflation it would be closer in price to the Billy you bought 25 years ago.

Assuming a product introduced 25 years ago has exactly the same role in the lineup today sounds crazy to me TBH.


Isn't that the point though?

Quality of the basic model Maytag washer I bought 25 years ago versus one today. Quality of a Reese's cup I bought 25 years ago versus one today. Quality of Levi's I bought 25 years ago versus a pair today. Quality of the Billy that I bought 25 years ago versus today.

Quality of the Billy HAS declined.


That's fair if we only strictly care about the Billy line and it's history.

From there we can't generalize to any other product without acknowledging IKEA's internal decision process or their vision for Billy across the years.

To parent's point

> where the inflection point is where used items become more valuable than the new items being made at current quality levels, including degradation due to age.

Buying the actual modern equivalent of what Billy was 25 years ago answers that question.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: