Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

People called a genocide because if we wait for it to be bad enough to be called a genocide by even the most cynical person, too many people have died.

Quite frankly, the genocide of the Jewish people in Germany also started far sooner than just the final solution. But I guess "Never again" is just fancy words for pretenders.



> People called a genocide because if we wait for it to be bad enough to be called a genocide by even the most cynical person, too many people have died

No, what happened is the word got diluted into popular meaninglessness. ("It's not a war it's a genocide" doubling down on that mistake.) A lot of people called wolf early and often, and that did its damage. (I'm unconvinced they care. A lot of activism on this topic seems to be self serving.)

> the genocide of the Jewish people in Germany also started far sooner than just the final solution

Sure. We also didn't have international institutions whose job it is to investigate and identify genocide in WWII. Now we do. Turning "may be" and "at risk of" genocide into "is genocide" just means that when e.g. a credible UN agency determines it is genocide, the finding doesn't resonate.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: