Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

True enough... but I wonder (has anyone actually done this?) if you polled 1,000 "average americans" how many would be surprised and/or upset to find out that email is 100% not private, and it's not supposed to be. I bet a high, high proportion.

I guess the problem with an aggressive public campaign to educate consumers, is that there is no obvious alternative.



Why are people always talking about Americans? They seem to be pretty dumb...

Anyways, I strongly believe that as long as you living in a Western society it is your job to take care of your business. If I am taking part in any System which I did not check up to see if it is secure, I am voluntarily taking the Risk of using the System. I could for example set up an own E-Mail server, if I was coming to the Point that E-Mails are not secure enough on an external hoster. (If I searched for enough security related information about the "E-Mail" System.)


>hur dur amerikens r dumb

Your argument here is fallacious. In a perfect world, of course every service user would thoroughly research their providers before agreeing to their Terms of Service. The reason why that doesn't happen in real life is because not everyone is a sysadmin/developer/privacy lawyer. If each and every Gmail user spent the time necessary to thoroughly understand and interpret the legal nuances of email privacy, most of them wouldn't have any time left to go to work or take care of their families.

If we expected consumers to completely fend for themselves at all times, there'd be no need for the FDA, the CPA or, for that matter, the government. Why do you think these institutions were created in the first place? They came into being because the average consumer doesn't have time to become a food quality expert and tour the factories that make the products s/he buys. Similarly, the average Gmail user doesn't have time to learn and weigh the merits of Gmail's intricate privacy policy, nor does s/he have time to learn how to set up and secure his/her own email server.

To say that Americans are "dumb" because they're not all experts in the field that you do happen to understand professionally is stereotyping and offensive. Do you have a thorough understanding of pharmacology or refrigerator design or any of the other numerous fields' whose products you use on a daily basis? I didn't think so.


Probably the same people who think sending a letter is private. They just don't think of all the external factors.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: