Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

It could have been done twenty years ago, and it will not progress beyond what is shown here: causing a given muscle to twitch.

Transcranial magnetic stimulation is inherently imprecise and brutish. It causes all the neurons in the target brain area (3-4 cm^3) to discharge at once. Depending on the intensity of the stimulation, you can recruit more or less neurons, but it is not selective.

For most of the brain, it just disrupts the activity for less than a second, causing a "virtual lesion". This is useful for brain mapping research, but that's it.

When you zap the motor cortex, it also sends action potentials down the spine, which in turn stimulate the motor neurons then the muscles.

The hardware is bulky and unpractical [0]. You could maybe use two coils per brain hemisphere, and then, you must stimulate areas distant from one another.

For the foreseeable future the only mind control techniques are propaganda and manipulative behavior, with some drugs sprinkled in for good measure. No need to worry about this.

[0] https://www.google.com/search?q=transcranial+magnetic+stimul...




I don't care what that lunatic Alexander Graham Bell says, and I don't care what stupid little one-time demos he has in his lab, the telephone is never going to take off.


This approach is a dead end.

The electric resistance of the skull is way too high to send any useful information through electric stimulation, and magnetic stimulation is inherently blunt.

For the same reason, the complexity of the information that you can get with EEG is very limited. There's a lot of noise, and the spatial resolution is very coarse.

Useful brain to brain communication requires invasive surgery, in order to put sensors and stimulation electrodes next to the cortex. It will happen, and it will be revolutionary, but the method described in the article is not a progress in that direction.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: